|
However, on races such as the 40 yd
dash or 100 yd dash, this would not necessarily
translate into increased performance. This is because
under normal creatine conditions (not supplementing),
the body has enough creatine phosphate to last the
entire race. The limiting factor within these short
races is not your endurance at your highest intensity,
it is your highest intensity, how fast you can run.
However, if one were to perform repeated bouts of
sprints at a high intensity level while supplementing
with creatine, their endurance at this intensity would
be longer because their storage of creatine phosphate is
higher due to supplementation.
Creatine Helps Prevent Against Head Injuries?
Possibly. Some researchers at the
Sander's Brown Center for Aging fed rats and mice some
creatine for four weeks before hitting them on the head
in an attempt to create brain damage. The researchers
noted that brain damage was reduced by "as much as 36%
in mice and 50% in rats" (1). In many sports, people get
smacked in the head a lot, so taking creatine could help
prevent brain damage in the long run.
Side Effects of Creatine
The major side effect of creatine use
is creatine's ability to pull water into the muscle
cells. Because creatine takes water into the muscle
cells, many other tissues of the body may not be full
hydrated. In this environment, if not enough water is
taken in, it is much more likely that one can become
dehydrated. Therefore, it is VERY important to drink an
optimal amount of water while supplementing with
creatine. Creatineinformation.net recommends to "Drink
at least 1-2 ounces of water daily per kilogram of body
weight while supplementing".
Once again, because of creatine's
ability to draw water into the muscle cells, many
individuals experience a rapid weight gain. Some
individuals experience a 7-12 pound gain in weight
during the loading phase.
However, this can be mostly
attributed to water weight. Gaining 7-12 pounds of
muscle in that short of an amount of time is essentially
impossible due to the physiological limits of the human
body.
There are many other more minor side
effects which can be attributed to creatine use,
although most of them can be avoided by supplementing
with creatine in the correct way. A much more complete
list of side effects can be found at this website about
creatine.
Proper
Supplementation of Creatine
Many people believe in doing a
loading phase - usually 5 days followed by a maintenance
phase, followed by a wash-out phase during creatine
supplementation. A loading phase is not necessarily
required (you could just start out with the maintenance
phase and skip the loading phase), however it helps the
muscles become saturated with creatine faster. This
would mean that the maximum effects of creatine
supplementation could be experienced faster in one week
rather than four to six weeks. Anyways, here is a brief
summary of these phases.
The Loading Phase - The loading phase
consists of 5 days where the body will be loaded with
approximately .3 grams of creatine per kilogram of
bodyweight. It is strongly recommended to split the
dosages up into 4 or 5 times per day and take each
dosage with roughly 16 ounces of water. Taking a large
amount of creatine at the same time can put extra strain
on the kidneys, plus most of it won't even be
assimilated - it will just be eliminated from the body
through urine. A more specific guideline for taking
creatine can be found at Dr. Alfredo Franco-Obregon's
creatine calculator. Do not load for more than five days
consistently.
After completing the loading phase,
one should take a maintenance dosage everyday equal to
about .03 grams of creatine per kilogram of bodyweight.
Continue this for one month, then stop supplementation
for one month to allow for a "wash-out" phase.
Afterwards, repeat the loading phase and maintenance as
described above. Since the maintenance dosage is only
taken once per day, it is generally recommended to take
it with or after a meal. This will cause insulin to be
released which will help to "shuttle" creatine into the
muscle cells.
Creatine Frequently Asked Questions
Does
caffeine interfere with the effects of creatine?
No one is sure whether or not
caffeine
inhibits the effects of creatine, but one study shows
that they do conflict. Scientists gave one group of
their subjects creatine, and one group caffeine +
creatine. The scientists measured whether or not the
creatine was taken up into the cells, which it was even
in the group taking caffeine as well as
creatine. However, the group given caffeine + creatine
did not seem to show any beneficial effects, while the
group given pure creatine increased the amount of torque
they produced 10%-23% when they were compared to a group
given the placebo (2).
Will
creatine help with endurance type events?
There are a few studies testing the
benefits of creatine in endurance type events, but the
consensus remains unclear. In one study, subject with
the creatine supplementation performed better when they
performed 4 300 meter bouts and 4 1000 meter bouts
against a placebo (3).
My
friend is taking creatine and making HUGE GAINS! If I
took creatine I would make HUGE GAINS too, right?
Taking creatine does not induce "huge
gains". There are way too many other factors that play a
much more important role in your progress in any
sort of athletic endeavor or abilities. For instance, if
your diet is horrible, and you don't eat enough
calories, then this will greatly hinder your gains (a
much more detailed guide to this can be found at www.burn-the-fat-feed-the-muscle.com). Also, if you
train incorrectly, or you train way too much, this can
also hinder your gains. Creatine is a supplement and
being that, it only adds onto your original training and
diet base. Simply taking creatine isn't going to make
you huge all of the sudden (although it can add water
weight), especially without proper diet and
exercise. That being said, taking creatine incorrectly
will also alter the affects it has on you. Dr. A.
Franco-Obregón has compiled a huge and greatly detailed
guide about creatine and the exact ways to take it to
maximize gains. You can find his guide about creating by
clicking here.
Is
creatine banned in any athletic events?
Currently, there are no athletic
events that I know of in which creatine is a banned
substance. Although there are ways to find if extra
creatine is being supplemented by analyzing the urine,
in theory, these traces in the urine could be avoided by
taking in the correct amount of creatine (if you take
too much and you're body has trouble absorbing it all,
it will excrete it). However, since creatine is also
found in meat products one could simply eat a lot of
chicken or steak and the urine samples would read the
same. Therefore, the said athletic event would have to
ban all meat products as well...which is quite unlikely.
Can
women take creatine too?
There's really no reason in theory
why creatine wouldn't effect women in different than men
although most of the studies done on creatine were done
on men. However, one study done by K Vandenberghe and
other authors involving creatine and women shows that
creatine does benefit women, in a similar fashion to
men. Quoting from the study, "Compared with placebo,
maximal strength of the muscle groups trained, maximal
intermittent exercise capacity of the arm flexors, and
fat-free mass were increased 20-25, 10-25, and 60% more"
(4). It is currently not known how creatine affects
pregnant women.
I've heard of this new stuff called
creatine ethyl ester, is it any better than regular
creatine? Also, what about the other forms of creatine
such as tricreatine malate, dicreatine malate, creatine
phosphate, etc.
They either don't exist or I was
unable to find any studies involving creatine ethyl
ester, tricreatine malate, or dicreatine malate. A
common marketing tactic by companies is to confuse the
reader with big, scientific words and phrases that only
someone educated in that area would understand. Many
times when one encounters these new forms of creatine,
this type of marketing hype will surround them. So
either the companies selling these products have new
theories on delivering creatine to the muscle cell, or
they are making stuff up. Creatine phosphate, on the
other hand, provides the same type of beneficial effects
that creatine monohydrate does according to a study done
by Peeters BM and other authors (5). A very high
percentage, probably close to 99%, of creatine studies
use creatine in the form of creatine monohydrate.
What is
up with non-responders and responders to creatine?
It is generally not known as to why
people "respond" differently to creatine
supplementation. In this author's opinion though,
factors such as the previous amount of creatine in the
diet (a vegetarian would respond better than a meat
eater),
genetics, improper use of creatine (some people decide
that they want to take all 20 grams of their creatine at
once during the loading phase when the body can only
handle so much at once), body mass (a huge bodybuilder
is going to need more creatine than a bikini model),
food taken with creatine (eating a higher glycemic food
would heighten the insulin response and therefore shuttle
creatine more efficiently), and possibly the user
doesn't know that they are responding to the creatine (a
weight lifter or sprinter performing multiple bouts
would experience a greater effect than an endurance
runner).
Can
creatine improve brain performance?
It seems so,
researchers in Australia
tested this and came to the conclusion that "Creatine
supplementation had a significant positive effect on
both working memory (backward digit span) and
intelligence (Raven's Advanced Progressive Matrices),
both tasks that require speed of processing. These
findings underline a dynamic and significant role of
brain energy capacity in influencing brain
performance." In another study done at the University of
Tokyo researchers found at providing subjects with 8
grams of creatine for 5 days reduced mental fatigue when
"subjects repeatedly performed a simple mathematical
calculation." They also noted that the brain seemed to
use more oxygen (7).
Is
there a way to more efficiently shuttle creatine to the
muscles?
In theory, creating an insulin spike
(insulin is a substance in your body which shuttles
nutrients to where they are needed) will help to shuttle
creatine to the muscles. These findings are confirmed in
a study where subjects showed that ingesting 93 grams of
simple carbohydrates 30 minutes after supplementation
with creatine increased the total creatine amount of the
body by 60% compared to a group only ingesting creatine. The
researchers concluded with "these findings demonstrate
that carbohydrate ingestion substantially augments
muscle Creatine accumulation during Creatine feeding in
humans, which appears to be insulin mediated(8)."
If you're looking for much more
information on creatine, I would HIGHLY recommend
Dr.Alfredo Franco-Obregon's book,
"A Practical Guide to Creatine". Also, if you want
to use your diet to take your gains to the next level
(literally), then check out
Tom Venuto's "Burn the Fat, Feed the Muscle".
Here are a few studies testing the
efficacy of creatine:
|
Reference # |
Protocol |
Outcome |
|
9 |
Bench press for 5 sets with a 2 minute rest
period in between |
Creatine group performed higher number of
reps |
|
10 |
Performed 1 rep maximum, then performed as
many reps as possible at 70% of 1 rep
maximum |
Creatine group's 1 rep maximum increased and
number of reps at 70% of 1 rep maximum
increased performed increased |
|
11 |
Performed five 6 second bouts on a
stationary cycle at 140 revolutions per
minute with a 30 second recovery. At the
end, a 10 second bout was performed. |
The creatine group maintained their pedal
frequency longer at the end of the final 10
second bout. |
|
12 |
Performed three bouts each 30 seconds long
with a 4 minute rest period in between on a
stationary cycle at 80 revolutions per
minute. |
The creatine group increased their peak
power during the first bout and also
increased their average power output and
work during bouts 1 and 2. |
|
13 |
Nine resistance trained men supplemented
with 25 g of creatine daily as a loading
phase, then supplemented with 5 grams daily
as a maintenance of the creatine
supplementation. The men engaged in heavy
resistance training for 12 weeks |
In the creatine group, bench press increased
by 24% and squat increased by 32% while in
the placebo group, bench press increased by
16% and squat increased by 24%. |
|
14 |
5 bouts of 30 leg extensions with one leg
with a 1 minute rest period. |
Torque production did not decrease as much
during the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th bouts. |
References:
(1)
Sullivan P.G., Geiger J.D., Mattson M.P., Scheff S.W.
Dietary supplement creatine protects against traumatic
brain injury. Ann Neurol 2000 Nov;48(5):723-9
(2)
Vandenberghe K, et al. Caffeine counteracts the
ergogenic action of creatine loading. J Appl Physiol
1996;80:452.
(3) Harris
RC, et al. The effect of oral creatine supplementation
on running performance during maximal short-term
exercise in man. J Physiol 1993;467:74P
(4)
Vandenberghe K, et al. Long-term creatine intake is
beneficial to muscle performance during resistance
training.
J Appl Physiol 1997;83:2055.
(5) Peeters
BM, et al. Effect of oral creatine monohydrate and
creatine phosphate supplementation on maximal
strength indices, body composition, and blood pressure.
J Strength Cond Res 1999;113:3.
(6) Rae C,
et al. Oral creatine monohydrate supplementation
improves brain performance: a double-blind,
placebo-controlled, cross-over trial. Proc Biol Sci.
2003 Oct 22;270(1529):2147-50.
(7)
Watanabe A, Kato N, Kato T. Effects of creatine on
mental fatigue and cerebral hemoglobin oxygenation.
Neurosci Res 2002 Apr;42(4):279-85 Department of
Neuropsychiatry, Faculty of Medicine, University of
Tokyo.
(8) Green
AL, et al. Carbohydrate ingestion augments skeletal
muscle creatine accumulation during creatine
supplementation in humans. Am J Physiol 996;271:E821.
(9) Volek
Js, et al. Creatine supplementation enhances muscular
performance during high intensity resistance
exercise. J Am Diet Assoc 1997;97;765
(10)
Earnest CP, et al. The effect of creatine monohydrate
ingestion on anaerobic power indices, muscular
strength and body composition. Acta Physiol Scand 195;
153:207.
(11)
Soderlund K, et al. Creatine supplementation and
high-intensity exercise: influence on performance and
muscle metabolism. Clin Sci 1994;87 (suppl):120.
(12) Birch
R, et al. The influence of dietary creatine
supplementation and dynamic high-intensity intermittent
exercise. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 1995;3:143.
(13) Volek
JS, et al. Performance and muscle fiber adaptation to
creatine supplementation and heavy
resistance training.
(14)
Greenhaff PL, et al. Influence of oral creatine
supplementation on muscle torque during repeated bouts
on maximal voluntary exercise in
man. Clin Sci 1993;84:565 |